40 Comments

Gordon Lightfoot's The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald (the wrath of Lake Superior)

Expand full comment
author
Apr 25·edited Apr 25Author

It's such a classic. Never tire of hearing it. If it weren't so damned long, I'd likely have put it on the show. Great pick, my friend.

Expand full comment

I’m pretty sure it’s a state law that every bar in WI has to have this on the jukebox.

Expand full comment
author

Damn sure is in Michigan.

Expand full comment

All of Canada too!

Expand full comment

Talking Heads- Once In A Lifetime/Take me to the River/ Swamp

CSN- Southern Cross

The War On Drugs- An Ocean Between the Waves

PJ Harvey- Down By the Water

Meatpuppets- Lake of Fire

Expand full comment
author

Damn, I forgot PJ! Love that CSN track too. Nice.

Expand full comment

That PJ Harvey song is so good.

Expand full comment
author

That whole album is amazing. I was fortunate enough to see that tour. Woah Nelly was that amazing.

Expand full comment

Deep Purple, Smoke on the water.

I really want to suggest CSN, Southern Cross, but I don't think it actually mentions a body of water in the lyrics. Marquess's and Papeete are actually French Polynesia.

Down by the River, Neil Young.

Take me to the River. I prefer the Al Green version, but Talking Heads will do.

The Ocean, Led Zeppelin

Sittin on the dock of the Bay, Otis Redding. This one is so good.

Expand full comment

Southern Cross is a bit of a stretch, but it does mention a boat and a “following sea,” so I went with it.

Expand full comment

The judges will allow it.

Expand full comment

Strangford Lough in Van Morrison’s “Cony Island”

Expand full comment

Proud Mary by Creedence Clearwater Revival

Expand full comment
author

Nice call, Kent. I actually included a different CCR track. You can prolly guess which one.

Expand full comment

The lake in Allan Sherman’s “Camp Granada”

Expand full comment
author

Ha!

Expand full comment
Apr 25Liked by Matty C

Find The River - REM

Expand full comment
author

Love it. Gotta confess, this totally made the show this week. Great call.

Expand full comment

Enya - Orinoco Flow was the first song that came to my mind.

Pearl Jam - Oceans

Van Morrison - Into the Mystic (?)

How is it the Waterboys don’t have a song about a body of water?

Expand full comment
author

Same re: Waterboys. I was sure they would have something. Love that you included Enya. That track is catchy as shit, you gotta admit it.

Expand full comment

So catchy!! It’s been an earworm today! LOL

Expand full comment

Nice, and I'll also recommend Jen Chapin's cover of "Into the Mystic " https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a6FPsRk-HHE

Expand full comment

Aside from Gord’s - Wreck of The Edmund Fitzgerald (my Love is wrapping up Early Morning Pictures currently..)

CSN’s ‘Southern Cross’ for sure.. (Jimmy Buffet’s version is excellent too !)

Fred Neil’s ‘Searchin For The Dolphins’ plus ‘I’ve Got A Secret’ - same Album .. ‘skippin over the ocean like a storm..

The Clash - ‘London Calling’ .. .. I live by the river ..

Linda Ronstadt ‘Blue Bayou

Expand full comment
author

Great call on the Fred Neil. That track is beautiful. The Billy Bragg version of 'Dolphins' is quite good as well.

Expand full comment

this Buckley gem is another oh so good ‘live cover.. but Fred lived it.. owns it

He, Lightfoot & Jimmie Buffet were pals from back in the way before & all along the road.. will check out Billy Bragg thanks.. i need reminders like that .. thanks ! 🦎🏴‍☠️🐬

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJYdmaIByRA

Expand full comment

Three Stones in the River by Wilson Thicket - https://open.spotify.com/track/5wfwJCypUvkpo8CWARkWtC?si=66e2f54846d34acb

Expand full comment

Lake Erie, Last Summer by Nervous But Excited - https://open.spotify.com/track/7pAR7w8YfXzYGCz49RtZ4B?si=0e4b3f29ad9345fc

Expand full comment
Apr 25Liked by Matty C

I don't know about bodies of water in a song, but as far as songs featuring bodies of water, leaving off classics that everybody knows:

Gregory Alan Isakov - That Sea, the Gambler

Ramona Falls - Salt Sack

Expand full comment

Setting aside songs about boats (which could be it's own topic).

Otis Redding "Sittin On The Dock Of The Bay"[1] -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7C-VscEQugk

Norman Blake "The Keeper Of The Government Light On The River" -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8zuusFN8ljk

Tom Russell "Mississippi River Runnin' Backwards" (give it a minute; it kicks into gear a bit when it hits the chorus) -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IzUi5tXywac

Rosanne Cash "Miss The Mississippi And You": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lm8og-n3VEQ

Gordon Bok "Bay Of Fundy" -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9dgJJtEtQQ

(looking it up I find his description of the song: "This is about a long and weary, windless trip from Maine around to Halifax on a little black schooner that seemed to move only by the slatting of her gear. We had a coal stove in her, and the foresail used to downdraft onto the charlienoble, turn the stack into an intake and the cabin into a chimney. So, with the coalgas and the wet, the offwatch was not much more comfortable than the deadwatch."

[1] Credit where credit is due. While looking up songs I found this page in which a professor asked his students for songs that made them think of the Pacific Ocean, and "Dock Of The Bay" jumped out at me (the students comments are, as you might expect, trying a little too hard to come up with something that sounds smart -- but it's a good exercise): https://seanfraga.github.io/PacificPlaylist/

Expand full comment
author

These are great. I'd have to put 'Edmund Fitzgerald' at the top of a list of boat songs.

I'm gonna check that Gordon Bon song for sure. Thanks for the heads up.

Expand full comment

One other song I intended to mention. When I was growing up, I heard "Rivers of Texas" as a lullaby (nobody in my family was from Texas, they just liked the song).

The version that's closest to what I remember is Bill Staines: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2w50bVqfOL0

Looking it up I see that it has been done by Lyle Lovett: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=syQRcMjISYw

and Townes Van Zandt: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xiqtur_z3Zk

Expand full comment

Agreed about "Edmund Fitzgerald" (but there are more worth mentioning).

Expand full comment

Since my body is 60% water, my favorite song is anything that celebrates this Sea of Complexity That Is Me! So that would be this chestnut:

"No one's frightened of playing it

Everyone's saying it

Flowing more freely than wine

All through your life

I me mine!" —George Harrison

Expand full comment

“Roundabout” by Yes….but “in and around the lake” isn’t about a body of water so much as just a body. 🤣 I think it still kind of counts right?

Expand full comment

〜 Leon Bridges - "River"

〜 The Drums - "Down By The Water"

〜 Florence + The Machine - "What The Water Gave Me"

〜 The Kooks - "Seaside"

〜 Lykke Li, The Magician - "I Follow Rivers" (The Magician Remix)

Expand full comment